Saturday, November 14, 2026

Top 5 This Week

Related Posts

Two Simple Questions That Could Shatter The DOJ–FBI Cover-Up In U.S. v. Raniere And Leave Jack Smith Vulnerable

The Department of Justice believed this case was finished, safely sealed behind salacious headlines and the smug assumption that no one would ever bother to look under the hood. They were wrong.

Seven independent forensic experts, four of them former FBI examiners, have now concluded that the digital evidence prosecutors called “the heart” of their case in U.S. v. Keith Raniere was falsified and planted, with government involvement. A Newsweek-retained expert reached the same conclusion. A grand jury simulation found probable cause to indict the FBI agents involved.

After my reporting, a coordinated media blitz exploded. The New York Times, Rolling Stone, and Vanity Fair all recycled the DOJ’s original narrative, conspicuously ignoring the forensic evidence, in a blatant attempt to drown out the findings with character assassination and moral panic. But they failed.

Read More:

This entire scandal ultimately comes down to two very simple questions the FBI could answer today if it weren’t protecting itself. Those questions don’t just expose fraud in Raniere. They point directly to a much bigger problem, one that now intersects with Jack Smith and the most politically charged prosecutions in modern U.S. history.

The Examiner Who “Went to Ghana” and Never Returned

At trial, federal prosecutors told the court that FBI Senior Forensic Examiner Stephen Flatley, the original examiner of a camera memory card, was unavailable to testify because he had been “sent to Ghana” during the fifth week of the six-week trial.

image 171

That explanation mattered. Flatley had previously testified under oath in another case that timestamps are easily altered. That testimony would have destroyed the government’s timeline-dependent allegations. So Flatley disappeared into the ether at just the right moment. How convenient.

In his place, the government presented FBI Senior Forensic Examiner Booth, who told the jury the exact opposite, stating that timestamps are “difficult to modify,” a claim so obviously false that any layperson with a smartphone could disprove it. But it was also the testimony the prosecution needed to lock in its most prejudicial charges.

However, official records from Ghana now confirm that Flatley was never in Ghana during or after the trial, which means someone lied.

Either the FBI and DOJ falsely claimed Flatley was sent abroad to justify removing him from the stand or they retroactively created a paper “assignment” that never actually happened. If Flatley was quietly sidelined only to be replaced by an examiner who delivered testimony that sealed the defendant’s fate, then what we’re looking at isn’t incompetence, It’s orchestrated deception.

The Second Forensic Image the Court Was Never Supposed to See

The second question is even more damning. FBI protocol is explicit: investigators are allowed to create one forensic image of a device—a bit-for-bit snapshot. All analysis must be done from that image. You never go back to the device. Re-imaging is forbidden without written authorization from FBI Quantico’s Assistant Director.

No such authorization exists here. Flatley created the original forensic image. When Booth later entered the case, prosecutors insisted he merely issued a “replacement report” based on Flatley’s image. Assistant U.S. Attorney Tanya Hajjar even told the court that Booth never said he imaged the device himself.

That statement has now collapsed. The government has quietly admitted that Booth created a second forensic image five and a half years after the trial. That second image contains 37 files that were not in the original image. Seven forensic experts have determined that 28 of those files were falsified and planted.

image 172

At this point, the case should be over. The misconduct is glaring. Yet the DOJ refuses to answer the most basic question in digital forensics: Are the two images identical?

The answer takes seconds. You compare hash values – digital fingerprints that immediately confirm whether two files are the same. Instead of producing those hashes or releasing the second image, the DOJ blocked access entirely. Judges went along with it, and the FBI rolled out Senior Computer Scientist David Loveall II to neutralize the damage.

Loveall claimed the extra files were due to “different software settings.” He provided no hash values. He failed to establish image integrity. He didn’t even date his report—an omission that conveniently shields him from perjury exposure.

It was not expert analysis. It was a cover-up. If the images are identical, then Flatley concealed evidence, including falsified files.

If they are not identical, then files were planted in FBI custody, directly implicating multiple agents, supervisors, and prosecutors. Either way, it’s criminal.

Read More:

Why Jack Smith is Vulnerable

Four former FBI CART examiners have formally demanded that FBI Director Kash Patel release the withheld forensic image. The evidence trail is documented. The misconduct is no longer theoretical.

Just months after Loveall produced his cover-up report in U.S. v. Raniere, Jack Smith selected Loveall as a potential expert witness in the Mar-a-Lago prosecution of President Donald Trump. In his expert disclosure, Loveall claimed this was his only testimonial work in over four years.

image 173

Why did Jack Smith recruit a forensic official who had just helped obscure FBI and DOJ evidence tampering in another high-profile case?

That question has never been asked in court. It has never been answered by the DOJ, and it goes to the heart of whether federal law enforcement is enforcing the law or protecting itself.

During his hearing in front of the House Judiciary Committee on Thursday, January 22, 2026, Jack Smith avoided answering many key questions about his past questionable behavior, including actions he engaged in during his pursuit of President Trump throughout the 2024 Presidential election. This prompted President Trump to post on Truth Social, “Jack Smith is a deranged animal, who shouldn’t be allowed to practice law.”

image 174

These simple questions could be answered fully and truthfully; the only thing missing is the courage to demand them.

That’s why this story isn’t going away, and Jack Smith better keep his legal team on retainer for the foreseeable future.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Popular Articles

spot_img

Top 5 This Week

spot_img

Related Posts